Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1964 05 06 CC MIN1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«REGULAR MEETING OF THE BALcYJIN.PARK CITY COUNCIL MAY 6, 1964 CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBER) 14403 East Pacific Avenue 7:30 P.M. The City Council of the City of Baldwin Park met in regular session at the above place at 7.30 p.m. Councilman McCaron led the salute to the flag. FLAG SALUTE The invocation was given by Pastor Vernon Kutz of the INVOCATION Church of the Nazarene. Roll Call: Present: COUNCILMEN ADAIR, GREGORY, ROLL CALL MCCARON, TAYLOR AND MAYOR MOREHEAD 80 x. Absent: NONE Also Present:, CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER NOR%B'(, CITY ATTORNEY FLANDRICK, CITY ENGINEER YOUNG, PLANNING DIRECTOR AND BUILDING SUPERIN- TENDENT KALBFLEISCH, ASSISTANT PLANNING DIRECTOR HILL, FINANCE DIRECTOR DUNCAN, CHIEF OF POLICE BEST, CITY TREASURER PUGH AND CITY CLERK BALKUS 00- COUNCILWOMAN TAYLOR MOVED THAT THE MINUTES OF APRIL 15, 1964, MINUTES OF APRIL 15, AND APRIL 21, 1964, BE APPROVED AND FURTHER READING BE 1964 AND APRIL 21, WAIVED, MAYOR MOREHEAD SECONDED. The motion carried by PROVED AND the following vote: Fu';.:'' EAG:~G WA d) AYES: COUNC I L\'IOMAN TAYLOR, MAYOR N'AREHEAD, COUNCILMEN ADAIR, AND OCCARCN NOES; NONE ABSTAIN: COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY ABSENT: NONE 00- I City Clerk Balkus read in full a letter from Martin Gould dated April 22, 1964, which stated that Lot Split No. 301 required that he deed a, portion of land for a future street; that the plan for the proposed street had been abandoned and he requested that the City take the necessary steps to vacate this street and return the property to him. Planning Director Kalbfleisch stated the first lot northerly of this property was being developed as R-2; that the property the second lot south was already developed and the lot split approved without dedication; that it would be almost impossible to develop the future street at this location. COUNCILMAN MCCARON MOVED THAT THIS MATTER BE REFERRED TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A RECOMMENDATION. COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEN NCCARON, GREGORY, ADAIR, TAYLOR AND MAYOR MOREHEAD NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE 00- City Clerk Balker read in full a letter from the Baldwin Park Improvement Association, Incorporated, dated April 26, 1964, requesting funds for fireworks. LETTER FROM MARTIN GOULD DATED APRIL 22. 1964 REQUESTING POR. OF LAND DEDICATED FC; FUTURE ST. UNDER L.S NO. 301 BE VACATED REPORT BY PLAN. DIR. KALBFLEISCH MOTION MADE AND CARRIED THAT MATTER BE REFERRED TO P.C. FOR RECOMMENDATION LETTER FROM B.PK. IMPROVEMENT ASSOC., INC., DATED APRIL 21 1964, REQUESTING FUNDS FOR FIREWORKS Continued) BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«181 Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council Chief Administrative Officer Nordby stated that later in the meeting he had intended to request that the City May 6, 1964 Page 2 Council adjourn to Friday, May 8, 1964, for a report from the insurance persons in connection with the Retire- ment System and he would have an answer to the question of fireworks funds at that time. As there were no objections, Mayor Morehead stated this item would be held over until Friday at the recommendation of the Chief Administrative Officer. 00- City Clerk Balkus read in full a letter from the Yellow Cab Company, 0. D. Stalians, dated April 28, 1964, requesting a change of meter rates. Mayor Morehead commented on the memorandum prepared by City Clerk Balkus regarding this increase. As there were no objections, Mayor Morehead stated that this matter would be held over to the next regular meeting; that the City Clerk request that the Yellow Cab Company furnish a list for comparison of the cities they refer to in their letter where rates have been increased; and also obtain the date of the last rate increase. RESOLUTION NO. 64-95 Councilman McCaron stated that perhaps the Chief Administra- C.A.0, TO CONTACT tive Officer could contact the Yellow Cab Company as to the YELLOW CAB CO. RE need for their rate increase so the Council would know NEED FOR THEIR RATE whether this was justified. INCREASE Mr. Stalians asked if he could answer any questions regarding this letter. Mayor Morehead asked him to reserve any comments until such time as the Council was in a position to take further action. 00- Regarding proposed Resolution No. 64-95, City Attorney RES. NO. 64-95 Flandrick stated this resolution would permit the Chief CITY ATTY. FLANDRICK Administrative Officer to take the steps necessary to EXPLANATION cause the construction of the vault without going out for further bid; that two times the City had gone out RE CONSTRUCTION OF to bid and no bids were received; that the budgetary VAULT amount $8,500.00) had been indicated heretofore and the resolution would accomplish the construction subject to that budget limitation. City Clerk Balkus read Resolution No. 64-95 by title as RES. NO. 64-95 follows: MATTER HELD OVER TO FRI. MAY BY 1964 AT RECOMMENDATION OF C,A.0. LETTER FROM YELLDW CAB CO,., O.D. STALIA I DOTED APRIL 28, 1964, REQUESTING CHANGE OF METER RATES MEMO FROM CITY CLERK RE REQUEST MATTER HELD OVER TO NEXT REG., MTG. CITY CLERK TO REQLES- YELLOU CAB TO FURNISI LIST OF CITIES THEY REFER TO IN THEIR LETTER AND OBTAIN DATE OF LAST RATE INCREASE AUTHORIZING CON- STRUCTION OF A PUBLIC PROJECT VAULT) PUR- SUANT TO SECTION A RESOLUTION AF THE CITY COUNCIL OF 37905 OF GOVT. CODE THE CITY OF BALDWIN PARK AUTHORIZING OF STATE OF CALIF. THE CONSTRUCTION OF A PUBLIC PROJECT VAULT) PURSUANT TO SECTION 37905 OF THE GOVERNMENT CODE OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA" Continued) BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í« 964 1782 Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council May 6, Page 3 COUNCILMAN NCCARON MOVED THAT RESOLUTION NO. 64-95 BE APPROVED AND FURTHER READING BE WAIVED. COUNCILMAN ADAIR SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEN NCCARON, ADAIR, GREGORY, TAYLOR AND MAYOR MOREHEAD NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE 00- Regarding proposed Resolution No. 64-96, City Attorney Flandrick stated this resolution was in connection with Sewer District No. 62-A-1; that this resolution would set for public hearing the question of whether or not the changes as indicated in Section I b" should be accomplished. City Engineer Young explained the changes; that there was money in the contingency fund; that this would not change the cost of the Bond Issue; that changes must be decided during construction. Discussion followed wherein Mayor Morehead stated that material regarding items to be brought on the Agenda should be delivered to the Council prior to the meeting. City Clerk Balkus read Resolution No. 64-96 by title as follows: RESOLUTION NO. 64-96 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BALDWIN PARK SETTING A TIME AND PLACE FOR HEARING REGARDING PROPOSED CHANGES IN THE WORK FOR ASSESSMENT DISTRICT NO. 62-A-I" COUNCILMAN hr-CARON MOVED THAT RESOLUTION NO. 64-96 BE APPROVED AND FURTHER READING BE WAIVED. COUNCILWOMt1AN GREGORY SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEN MCCARON, GREGORY, ADAIR, TAYLOR AND MAYOR hZREHEAD NOES: NONE ABSENT NONE 00- The Council agreed that the claims and demands resolution would be taken next. City Clerk Balkus read Resolution No. 64-91 by title as follows: RESOLUTION NO. 64-91 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SALDV41N PARK ALLCV41NG CLAIMS AND DEMANDS AGAINST THE CITY OF BALDWIN PARK" RES. NO. 64-95 ADOPTED RES. NO. 64-96 CITY ATTY. FLANDRICK EXPLANAT ION CITY ENGR. YOUNG EXPLANATION MATERIAL RE ITEMS TO BE BROUGHT ON AGENDA TO BE DEL IVEF TO COUNC I L PRIOR TO MTG. RES. NO. 64-96 SETT I NG TIME AND PLACE FOR HEARING RE PROPOSED CHANGES IN WORK FOR ASSESS- MENT DISTRICT NO. 62-A-I RES, NO. 64-96 ADOPTED CLAIMS AND DEMANDS TAKEN NEXT RES. NO. 64-91 ALLCHING CLAIMS AND DEMANDS AGAINST CITY OF B,PK. PAYROLL CLAIMS AN1 DEMANDS NOS. 4057- 4171 INCL. GENERAL CLAIMS ANI DEMANDS NOS. 4408- 4470 AND 51-54 INCL Continued) BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council MAYOR MOREHEAD MOVED THAT RESOLUTION NO. 64-91 BE APPROVED AND FURTHER READING BE WAIVED. COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: MAYOR MOREHEAD, COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY, COUNCILMEN ADAIR, MCCARON AND TAYLOR NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE 00- Regarding proposed Resolution No. 64-94, Finance Director Duncan explained this was for one warrant only; that it was for the withholding taxes deposit which must be made before May 15, 1964. City Clerk Balkus read Resolution No. 64-94 by title as follows: RESOLUTION NO. 64-94 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BALDWIN PARK ALLOWING CLAIMS AND DEMANDS AGAINST THE CITY OF BA LDW I N PARK" COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT RESOLUTION NO. 64-94 BE APPROVED AND FURTHER READING BE WAIVED, MAYOR MOREHEAD SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY, MAYOR MOREHEAD, COUNCILMEN ADAIR, MCCARON AND TAYLOR NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE 00- Mayor Morehead stated that Finance Director Duncan and City Treasurer Pugh were excused unless they desired to stay. Finance Director Duncan left the meeting 7:58 p.m.) 00- City Clerk Balkus read Resolution No. 64-92 by title as follows: RESOLUTION NO. 64-92 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BALDWIN PARK DESIGNATING THE CITY'S REPRESENTATIVES, AND ALTERNATES, TO CERTAIN MUNICIPAL COMMITTEES AND ORGANIZATIONS" City Attorney Flandrick stated this resolution would confirm the action of the City Council at their last regular meeting; that some of the organizations required that the appointments be made by resolution. COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT RESOLUTION NO. 64-92 BE APPROVED AND FURTHER READING BE WAIVED. MAYOR MOREHEAD SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY, MAYOR MOREHEAD, COUNCILMEN ADAIR, MCCARON AND TAYLOR NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE May 6, 1964 Page 4 RES. NO. 64-91 ADOPTED RES. NO. 64-94 WITHHOLDING TAXES DEPOS IT RES. NO. 64-94 ALLCV4ING CLAIMS AND DEMANDS AGA I NST CITY OF B.PK. GENERAL CLAIMS AND DEMANDS NO. 4471 RES. NO. 64-94 ADOPTED FINANCE DIRECTOR DUNCAN AND CITY TREASURER PUGH WERE EXCUSED UNLESS DE- SIRED TO STAY FINANCE DIRECTOR DUNCAN LEFT THE MTG. 7:58 p.m.) RES. NO. 64-92 DESIGNATING CITY'S REPRESENTATIVES, AN!' ALTERNATES, TO CER- TAIN MUNICIPAL COMMITTEES AND ORGANIZATIONS RES. NO. 64-92 ADOPTED 00- BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council There was discussion regarding the number of public hearings and the possible continuance of some if the meeting con- tinued to a late hour. 00- Mr. David C. Marcus, 215 West Fifth Street, Los Angeles, asked if the City Council would consider a request for a continuance at this time. CP-14). City Attorney Flandrick stated, regarding his memorandum on the zoning hearings, that his recommendation was that the City Council take no final action this evening until the three new Council members had reviewed all of the staff reports and evidence submitted. Planning Director Kalbfleisch stated that Council had copies of the reports that he had regarding this matter. As there was no objection from the Council, Mayor Morehead stated that CP-14 would be considered at this time. City Clerk Balkus announced that it was the time and place fixed for the continuation of a public hearing on CP-14, an application initiated by the Baldwin Park Planning Commission to initiate action pursuant to the revocation of Conditional Use Permit Special Use Permit). Case Number Z--86, Baldwin Auto Wreckers, for non-compliance of conditions as set forth in Resolution No. 61-167. The property is located at 5048-5056 North Merced Avenue. City Clerk Balkus stated that the required publication, postings and mailings had been accomplished. City Clerk Balkus administered the oath to those in the audience desiring to be heard during the meeting. TESTIMONY IN BEHALF OF NOT REVOKING THE PERMIT WAS CALLED FOR BY MAYOR OREHEAD, May 6, 1964 Page 5 RE CP-14 DAVID C. MARCUS, 215 W. Fifth St., L.A. rx4 CITY ATTY. FLANDRICK RECOMMENDED NO FINAL ACTION UNTIL THREE NEW COUNCIL MEMBERS HAD REVIEWED ALL OF STAFF REPORTS AND EVIDENCE SUBMITTED PUBLIC HEARING 8:00 P.M. CP-14 CONT=D FROM APRIL 15, 1964) INITIATED BY B.PK. P.C. TO INITIATE ACTION PURSUANT TO REVOCATION OF CONDI- TIONAL USE PERMIT SPECIAL USE PERMIT) CASE NO. Z-86, BALM'. AUTO WRECKERS, FOR NON-COMPLIANCE OF CONDITIONS AS SET FORTH IN RES. NO. 61-167 PROPERTY LOCATED AT 5048-5056 N. MERCED AVE. PUBLICATION, POSTING AND MAILINGS OATH ADMINISTERED BY CITY CLERK TESTIMONY IN BEHALF ELLEN BALDWIN, 1307C Francisquito, B.Pk. the requirements demanded were ridiculous;that the wrecking yard did more good for the youth of Baldwin Park than a lot of people even knew about; that Baldwin Park did not have another wrecking yard; that if discontinued people would have to go to El Monte or Azusa; that the Council should consider that Baldwin Auto Wreckers existed be- fore the City incorporated. Ellen Baldwin, 13070 Francisquito, Baldwin Park, stated she had followed this matter closely for approximately four 4) years; that Mr. Irving happened to have grand- father rights; that he was not bothering anyone; that Mr. James Q. Gibson, 13268 Francisquito Avelwe, Baldwin JAMES Q. GIBSON, Park, stated he also had been following this case for a 13268 Francisquito number of years; that he had previously contended and still Ave. contended that the. conditions imposed upon Mr. Irving and his business were unreasonable; that the previous Councils had been most lenient; that every time Mr. Irving appeared Continued) BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«1785 Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council in the Council Chamber there had been testimony for but not against his business. He stated this business was typical of American free enterprise; that he thought the City Council should be trying to see what they could do to perpetuate this kind of business rather than trying to destroy it, Mr. Dennis Irving, 810 Via Escalita, Glendora, owner of the Baldwin Auto Wreckers, thanked Mr. Gibson and his group for the factual remarks that he made. Mr. Gibson thanked Mr. Irving but said that he was not representing anyone but-James Q. Gibson. City Attorney Flandrick stated that the hearing could be closed or continued; that Mr. Kalbfleisch had reports that he did not believe Mr. Dennis Irving and his attorney had seen yet; that if the Council was going to con- sider those he would suggest that the City Council continue the hearing or at least give them copies this evening before making any final decision. COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT THE PUBLIC HEARING ON CP-14 BE CONTINUED TO JULY 15, 1964, WHICH IS APPROXIMATELY SIXTY 60) DAYS. COUNCILMAN MCCARON SECONDED. Councilman McCaron stated that copies of the report of the Fire Department should be given to each Council member and possibly other information would be needed. Mayor Morehead, with the approval of the Council, asked Planning Director Kalbfleisch to furnish the Council with anything that he had not furnished already with regard to this case as quickly as he could. At the suggestion of City Attorney Flandrick, Mayor Morehead asked that Mr. Kalbfleisch furnish the three new members of the City Council copies of the Planning Commission and City Council minutes relating to this matter as well as any staff reports. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEN GREGORY, MCCARON, ADAIR, TAYLOR AND MAYOR MOREHEAD NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE 00- City Clerk Balkus announced that it was the time and place fixed for the continuation of a public hearing on Z-217, an appeal from the denial of the Planning Commission, an application submitted by A. W. and Golda Cole and T. A. and Mary Colwick for a change of zone from C-1 neighborhood commercial zone) and R-I single family residential zone) to R-3 heavy multiple family residential zone) or more restrictive use on certain real property located at 4642 and 4646 North Maine Avenue. City Clerk Balkus stated that proper publication and mailings had been accomplished. May 6, 1964 Page 6 DENNIS IRVING, 810 Via Escalita, Glendora, OWNER BALDWIN AUTO WRECKEF SUGGESTION BY CITY ATTY. FLANDRICK MOTION MADE THAT PUBLIC HEARING ON CP-14 BE CONT'D TO JULY 15, 1964 FIRE DEPT. REPORT TO BE GIVEN TO EACH COUNCIL MEMBER PLAN. DIR. TO FURNIS COUNCIL WITH ANYTHIN NOT FURNISHED ALREAD PLAN, DIR. TO FURNIS: NEW COUNCIL MEMBERS WITH COPIES OF P.C. MINUTES AND CITY COUNCIL MINUTES RE THIS MATTER AS WELL AS ANY STAFF REPORTS MOTION CARRIED PUBLIC HEARING Z-217 CONT ID FROM APRIL 15,.1964) APPEAL FROM DENIAL OF P.C. REQUESTING ZONE CHANGE FROM C-I AND R-I TO R-3 AT 4642 AND 4646 N. MAINE AVE., A.W. AND GOLDA COLE AND T.A. AND MARY COUVIC PUBLICATION AND MAILINGS Continued) BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council May 6, 1964 Page 7 Planning Director Kalbfleisch presented a resume of the RESUME case and stated that the Planning Commission had adopted Resolution No. PC 64-36 denying this case on March 11, 1964. TESTIMONY IN BEHALF OF THE REQUEST WAS CALLED FOR BY TESTIMONY IN BEHALF MAYOR MOREHEAD. Mr. Tom Colwick, 3438 North Maine, Baldwin Park, stated TOM COLWICK, 3438 Mr. Cole and he owned the property; that they purchased N. Maine, B.Pk. the land about two 2) years ago; that at the time they purchased the land they came to the Building Department of the City and checked the zone; that they were told that it was C-1 on the front one hundred and fifty 150) feet and the remainder was R-3; that this zoning had been granted sometime before; that they had heard the rumor that there was a time limit on this zoning and asked if there was; that they had been told not and therefore went into escrow and purchased the ground; that later they sold the property; that the prospective) new owners checked the zone and were told it was C-1 and R-3; that they went to escrow and learned that there was a time limit; that his partner had talked with the City Attorney; that they had applied for a zone change and asked for the entire parcel to be R-3 and were denied by the Planning Commission on a vote of 3-2; that the Planning Commission felt that the C-1 zone on Maine should not be broken up; that they now felt that the C-I and R-3 would be better for everyone concerned; that they must have the R-3 in the back for the best use for the land; that it was six hundred 600) feet deep; that this matter had been on the Agenda since January and they would like to have a decision as soon as possible. Mr. Jerry Hammond, 14022 Ramona Boulevard, Baldwin Park, JERRY HA!A\OND, 14022 stated he was from Areo Homes and they were purchasing Ramona Blvd., B.Pk. the property from Mr. Colwick; that they felt this would be a desirable area for apartments; that they had come to the City Hall several times before purchasing the property and it was stated to them several times that it was R-3 in the back; that he started plans on the property and got quite a way along when the person who was drawing the plans came down to check and Mr. Kalbfleisch stated that the Council had made a mistake on the zoning; that it was an illegal rezone and they would have to come back in for a zone change again. As there was no one else in the audience desiring to speak PUBLIC HEARING either in behalf of or in opposition to Z-217, Mayor DECLARED CLOSED Morehead declared the public hearing closed. Z-217 In answer to a question by Mayor Morehead, Planning Director Kalbfleisch stated the land was R-3 only through a variance procedure and this was not a legal zone change and was only good for a period of one year as he recalled the original Zoning Ordinance. City Attorney Flandrick stated that he had the file; that there was a variance application to permit multiple family dwellings on the property; that the variance had expired and therefore the property reverted to its initial status. Councilman McCaron stated at the time the Master Plan was drawn up it was suggested that all of the property that was C-1 on Maine should revert to R-1 and the owners of all of the property would not concur with the suggestion so it remained C-1 as shown and the part in the rear R-I; that it appeared in some cases the tendency was to go to residential development; i h:. in this case it was R-3; that the residential development on the other side of the street was still in existence; that there had been no tendency toward C-1 and he thought that possibly there should be another Continued) BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«Regular fleeting of the Baldwin Palk City Council May 6, 1964 Page 8 study made of Maine Avenue by Simon Eisner and reassess SUGGESTED STUDY MADE the idea of whether or not the C-l should remain and the OF MAINE AVE. BY property owners contacted to see what their desire was at CONSULTANTS WHO DREW the present time; that it might be that they wished to go UP MASTER PLAN, SIMC to R-3 and relinquish the C-1; that it would appear that EISNER AND CO. AND their wishes should be obtained; that there should be an REASSESS IDEA OF access; that it was too deep for R-3 development as such WHETHER OR NOT C-I by itself; that possibly there could be entrance from SHOULD REMAIN AND Cavette and the lot next to it should be taken into PROPERTY OWNERS consideration; that there should be a definite trend; CONTACTED that once the decision was made it should be adhered to so that development could proceed along certain lines; that it was brought out at the Planning Commission meetings by testimony that if additional people ii-ve on these lots there would be more children and increase the cost of schools; that there should be some ii fiormation from the schools as to the future t-inanc-ing; that it would not be fair to the City as a whoi:e to iaerease the school tax burden unless there was sre-other way of taxation rather than taxation on property..i4seif to where the cost was distributed evenly; that be recognized that this was not only a local problem but a State problem. Regarding the pry Zoning Ordinance, Councilwoman Taylor RE PROPOSED ZONING asked if the peopi_e.would be caught in the transition as they ORD, were before. City Attorney-Flat)driek stated it would depend upon what the Council did with this particular case; that assuming the Council was go-i:ng to be in favor of rezoning the property, the case would have to be referred to the Planning Commission for a report; that they would have different regulations to be confronted with in terms of their actual development if the Zoning Ordinance was adopted substantially in its proposed form. Councilwoman Gregory suggested a survey of R-3 property COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY or at least apartment houses. She stated that the City SUGGESTED SURVEY OF could become a City of empty apartments. R-3 PROPERTY Councilman Adair stated he did not know how the property could be developed other than the way requested. Planning Director Kalbfleisch explained problems con- EXPLANATION BY PLAN. cerning the variance granted February 5, 1962: that DIR. KALBFLEISCH RE the property was advertised by the Planning Commission PRIOR VARIANCE GRANT and City Council as 4656 which would be adjacent to the subject property; that this was requested as a change of zone and was granted a variance only and that theivariance would be only good for one year. Councilwoman Taylor stated she thought Mr. McCaron's suggestion was a good one and asked how this could be accomplished. Councilman McCaron stated there were other zoning items on the Agenda that should be studied. The Council instructed the Chief Administrative Officer to contact Simon Eisner for information as to the charges for such a survey. Councilman McCaron stated the areas that should be studied would be: from Francisquito to Baldwin Park Boulevard and Merced Avenue, Vineland south of freeway,and the area on North Maine; and he was sure Mr. Kalbfleisch was aware of other areas that needed study. COUNCILMAN MCCARON OTHER ITEMS ON THE AGENDA THAT SHOULD BE STUDIED COUNCIL INSTRUCTION C.A.O. TO CONTACT SIMON EISNER AND GET INFORMATION AS TJO THEIR CHARGES FOR SUCH A SURVEY Continued) BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«U Regular PAeeting of the Baldwin Park City Council Discussion followed as to how long a study would take wherein Planning Director Kalbfleisch stated in his opinion it would take two or three months. Discussion followed regarding the ingress and egress wherein Councilman McCaron stated that the survey could determine how this would be done and also determine lot sizes. City Attorney Flandrick stated there is a provision in the existing ordinance which provided that a decision shall" be made within thirty 30) days; however this was not a mandatory provision, merely directory. Councilwoman Taylor asked P:1r. Colwick what the plan was for ingress and egress. Mr. Colwick stated in the original agreement there was twenty-five 25) feet from the southern boundary of the property off of Maine; that the property did not have ingress and egress to Cavette. Mr. Bill Howard from Areo Construction Company) stated there had been tentative arrangements to purchase a piece of property on Cavette Place. Discussion followed regarding the property to the north wherein Mr. Hammond stated he had the property in escrow at one time; that the Planning Commission took so long deciding that the owner took the property out of escrow. COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT Z-217 BE DENIED AND THE CITY ATTORNEY DIRECTED TO PREPARE A RESOLUTION OF DENIAL, The motion died for lack of a second.. COUNCILMAN MCCARON hIOVED THAT Z-217 BE POSTPONED UNT I L MAY 20, 1964, AND IN THE MEANTIME VIE HAVE SOMETHING FROM THE RESULTS OF SIMON EISNER INQUIRY AND THAT IF.IT IS FEASIBLE THAT THEY GIVE US THE STUDY ON THIS PARTICULAR PORTION FIRST AND DON'T WAIT FOR A COMPLETE REPORT. COUNCILWOMAN TAYLOR SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEN MCCARON, TAYLOR, ADA I R AND MAYOR MOREHEAD NOES: COUNC I LVIOhAN GREGORY ABSENT: NONE 00- City Clerk Balkus announced that it was the time and place fixed for the continuation of a public hearing on Z-222, an appeal from the denial of the Planning Commission, an application submitted by Sol and Esther Gura for a change of zone from A-1 light agricultural zone) to R-3 heavy multiple family residential zone) or more restrictive use on certain real property located at 3464, 3510, 3536 and 3538 North Maine Avenue. City Clerk Balkus stated that proper publication and mailings had been accomplished. Planning Director Kalbfleisch presented a resume of the case and stated that the Planning Commission had adopted Resolution PC 64-39 denying this case on March 11, 1964. font i rued May 6, 1964 Page 9 SURVEY WOULD TAKE TWO OR THREE MONTHS SURVEY COULD INCLUDE INGRESS AND EGRESS AND LOT SIZES RE INGRESS AND EGRES! MOTION MADE MOTION DIED FOR LACK OF SECOND MOTION MADE AND CARRIED THAT Z-217 BE POSTPONED UNTIL MAY 20, 1964, AND I N MEANTIME VIE HAVE SOMETHING FROM RE- SULTS OF SIMDN EISNE INQUIRY AND THAT IF IT IS FEASIBLE THAT THEY GIVE US STUDY ON THIS PARTICULAR PORTION FIRST AND DON T VIA I T FOR COMPLETE REPORT PUBLIC HEARING Z-222 CONT D FROM APRIL 15, 1964) APPEAL FROM DENIAL OF P.C. REQUESTING ZONE CHG. FROM A-l TO R-3 AT 3464, 3510, 3536 AND 3538 N. MAINE AVE., SOL AND ESTHER GURA PUBLICATION AND MA I L I NGS RESUME BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«Ir. 1.1 Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council May 6, 1964 Page 10 TESTIMONY IN BEHALF OF THE REQUEST WAS CALLED FOR BY TESTIMONY IN BEHALF MAYOR MOREHEAD, Mrs. Esther Gura, 3538 North Maine Avenue, Baldwin Park, MRS. ESTHER GURA, handed to the Council members a letter stating her p538 N. Maine Ave., testimony in favor of the request and read the letter B.Pk. in full letter in official files). As there was no one else in the audience desiring to speak PUBLIC HEARING either in behalf of or in opposition to Z-222, Mayor DECLARED CLOSED Morehead declared the public hearing closed. Z-222 Councilman McCaron stated that Maine Avenue was a sixty 60) foot street; that surrounding area was R-l; that in his opinion R-3 should be extended on major and secondary highways, not along the local streets; that there were small lots around this area. Discussion followed wherein it was brought out that Paddy Lane was a sixty 60) foot street. COUNCILMAN NCCARON MOVED THAT THE CITY ATTORNEY BE IN- MOTION MADE AND STRUCTED TO DRAW THE NECESSARY RESOLUTION DENYING ZONE CARRIED THAT CITY CASE Z-222. COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY SECONDED, The motion ATTY. BE INSTRUCTED carried by the following vote: TO DRAW NEC. RES. DENYING Z-222 AYES: COUNCILMEN MCCARON, GREGORY, ADAIR, TAYLOR AND MAYOR MOREHEAD NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE 00- City Clerk Balkus announced that it was the time and place PUBLIC HEARING fixed for the continuation of a public hearing on Z-226, an application submitted by Bob Lloyd, Agent for Paul C. Z-226 CONT'D FROM Duncan, et al for a change of zone from R-I single family APRIL 15, 1964) residential zone) to R-3 heavy multiple family residential REQUESTING CHANGE OF zone) or more restrictive use on certain real property' ZONE FROM R-I TO R-3 bounded by Foster Avenue on the north; Baldwin Paris Boulevard d N PROPERTY BOUNDED on the east; Corak Street on the south; the Sierra Vista BY FOSTER AVE., B.PK Junior High School property on the west; except the BLVD.. CORAK ST., westerly 84 feet of Lot 22 known as 13573 Corak Street. SIERRA VISTA JR. HIG SCHOOL ON WEST; EX- CEPT WESTERLY 84 FT. OF LOT 22 KNOJN AS 13573 CORAK ST 0 BOB LLOYD, AGENT FOR PAUL C. DUNCAN, ET A. City Clerk Balkus stated the proper publication and PUBLICATION AND mailings had been accomplished. MAILINGS Planning Director Kalbfleisch presented a resume of the case and stated that the Planning Commission had adopted Resolution PC 64-47 recommending approval on March 25, 1964. RESUME TESTIMONY IN BEHALF OF THE REQUEST WAS CALLED FOR BY TESTIMONY IN BEHALF MAYOR MOREHEAD. Mr. Paul C. Duncan, 13630 East Foster, Baldwin Park, PAUL C. DUNCAN, 1363: stated he was speaking for the sixteen property owners E. Foster, B.Pk. involved in this request; that there were approximately six and one-half 6k) to seven 7) acres involved; that it was approximately one 1) square block; that some of the reasons they were requesting the zone change were: the area involved at present was comprised primarily of single family dwellings; that most of the dwellings were of an older nature; that a majority of the properties consist of large deep lots; that his property was approxi- mately one I) acre; that the property next door to him Continued) BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«I Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council was approximately one and one-third 1 1/3) acres; that a zone change would eliminate these old structures; that a zone change would also allow the maximum use of the large lots; that it would upgrade the area; that this was important because Baldwin Park Boulevard was at present being widened into a one hundred 100) foot street and they felt this street would be a main entrance into the City of Baldwin Park; that in their opinion this area was the most ideal location for multiple dwellings due to it being so close to the freeway where there was an on and off ramp; that cities on either side of Baldwin Park had taken advantage of the property along the freeway for multiple dwellings; that a zone change in this area would not be a spot zoning; that the properties at present on the north side bordering Foster and also Baldwin Park Boulevard were R-3; that the property on the east had also been changed to R-3 and were now building; that they respectfully re- quested that the properties in the request be rezoned to R-3; that he felt this piece of property was a little different than some of the other which had been discussed; that there would be a one hundred 100) foot highway which would follow along the east end of all of this property; that there would be no problem of egress and ingress. As there was no one else in the audience desiring to speak either in behalf of or in opposition to Z-226, Mayor Morehead declared the public hearing closed. Discussion followed. Councilman McCaron stated this property was part of the property he had in mind that should have been studied; that it would be feasible to rezone; that the size of the lots needed study. He asked if the application was signed by all of the property owners. Mr. Duncan stated that all of the property owners had signed the petition, and Mr. Kalbfleisch verified this statement. City Attorney Flandrick stated that the City could not force persons to sell or trade property; that the City could create, by zoning regulations, nonconforming lots but this would not solve the problem; that the Council could request the applicant to file a subdivision map before the Council took any final action onthe zoning. Discussion followed. In answer to a question by Councilman McCaron, Planning Director Kalbf+'eisch stated in his opinion the City should maintain fifty-four 54) feet in width in order to obtain an actual turning radius of twenty-nine 29) plus twenty-five 25) for garage area on this property; that these lots could be combined and developed properly. City Clerk Backus read Ordinance No. 351 by title as follows: ORDINANCE NO. 351 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BALDW I N PARK AMENDING THE ZONING MAP OF SAID CITY AND REZONING CERTAIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY FROM R-I TO R_3" COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT ORDINANCE NO. 351 PASS FIRST READING AND FURTHER READING BE WAIVED. COUNCILMAN ADAIR SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: Continued) May 6, 1964 Page II PUBLIC HEARING DECLARED CLOSED Z-226 179o ORD. NO. 351 AMEND. ZONING MAP CF SAID CITY AND REZONING CERTAIN DESCR;BED PROPERTY FROM R-1 TO R-3 ORD. NO. 351 PASSED FIRST READING AND FURTHER READING WA I VED BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council of Baldwin Park Boulevard; that CP-35 public hearing on this Agenda) was a request for a service station on this property. As there were no objections, Mayor Morehead reopened the public hearing on Z-228. Mr. Perlin stated that the Planning Commission required that a detailed plot plan with all dimensions on it be submitted including copies of the rendering; that the conditional use permit CP-35) would be conditioned, if approved, on their making that plot plan. Mr. Perlin stated that a lease was signed and a second lease would be signed if the zone change was granted; that comnittments had been made; that by the end of the summer the developments would be in place. He brought out that there were people to the north and west of the property in favor of this zone change. In answer to a question by Councilman McCaron, Mr. Snyder stated his property was included in this zone change. As there was no one else in the audience desiring to speak either in behalf of or in opposition to Z-228, Mayor Morehead declared the public hearing closed. City Clerk Balkus read Ordinance No. 352 by title as follows: ORDINANCE NO. 352 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BALDW I N PARK AMENDING THE ZONING MAP OF SAID CITY AND RE- ZONING CERTAIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY FROM R-3 TO C-2" COUNCILWOMAN TAYLOR MOVED THAT ORDINANCE NO. 352 PASS FIRST READING AND FURTHER READING BE'VAIVED. COUNCIL- WOMAN GREGORY SECONDED. Councilman McCaron stated to achieve what the Council anticipated was to happen on this property a zone variance could be granted. City Attorney Flandrick stated in his opinion that a zone variance should not be used to permit a variance in use. Councilman McCaron stated that a zone variance would serve its purpose as a control factor for the facilities that were put on the area. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEN TAYLOR, GREGORY, ADAIR AND MAYOR MOREHEAD NOES: COUNCILMAN MCCARON ABSENT: NONE May 6, 1964 Page 13 PUBLIC HEARING REOPENED Z-228 MR. PERLIN MR. SNYDER PUBLIC HEARING DECLARED CLOSED Z-228 ORD NO. 352 AMEND. ZONING MAP OF SAID CITY AND REZONING CERTAIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY FROM R-3 TO C-2 MOTION MADE THAT ORD. NO. 352 PASS FIRST READING AND FURTHER READING BE WAIVED CITY ATTY. OPINION THAT ZONE VARIANCE SHOULD NOT BE USED TO PERMIT VARIANCE I N USE COUNCILMAN MCCARON STATED ZONE VARIANCE WOULD SERVE PURPOSE OF CONTROL FACTOR FOR FACILITIES PUT ON THE AREA ORD. NO. 352 PASSED FIRST READING AND FURTHER READING WAIVEr 00- BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«j 7 9 3 Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council City Clerk Balkus announced that it was the time and place fixed for the continuation of a public hearing on CP-35, an application submitted by Bernard Perlin for a Conditional Use Permit to allow the construction and use of an Automobile Service Station, in R-3 heavy multiple family residential zone), Proposed Zone C-2 general commercial zone- Case No. Z-228), on certain real property located at the southwesterly corner of Baldwin Park Boulevard and Tracy Street. City Clerk Balkus stated that the proper publication, mailings and postings had been accomplished. Planning Director Kalbfleisch presented a resume of the case and stated that the Planning Commission had adopted Resolution PC 64-45 recommending approval on March 11, 1964. TESTIMONY IN BEHALF OF THE REQUEST WAS CALLED FOR BY MAYOR MORE H EAD Mr. Bernard Perlin. 1044 Montego Drive, Los Angeles, pointed out that the conditions of the Planning Commiission required a ranch type service station with gabled roof with rock treatment; that the coffee shop would be similar; that the development as planned would be a real asset to the community and draw many people into Baldwin Park from the freeway. As there was no one else in the audience desiring to speak either in behalf of or in opposition to CP-35, Mayor Morehead declared the public hearing closed. Discussion followed. COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL CONCUR WITH THE RECOMMENDATION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION THAT CP-35 BE APPROVED AND THAT THE CITY ATTORNEY BE INSTRUCTED TO DRAW THE NECESSARY RESOLUTION, COUNCILMAN MOREHEAD SECONDED. In answer to a question by Councilwoman Taylor, Mayor Morehead stated under Section 2 a" curbs, gutters and sidewalks were required. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY p MAYOR MOREHEAD, COUNCILMEN ADAIR, NYCCARON AND TAYLOR NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE 00- City Clerk Balkus announced that it was the time and place fixed for the continuation of a public hearing on CP-30, an application submitted by Charles Hagerman and Marion Lellyett for a Conditional Use Permit to allow the construction and use of a dog kennel in M-1 light manufacturing zone) on certain real property located at 1337 North Virginia Avenue. City Clerk Balkus stated that the required publication, mailings and postings had been accomplished. Continued) May 6, 1964 Page 14 PUBLIC HEARING CP-35 CONT'D FROM APRIL 15, 1964) REQUEST TO ALL( 1 CONSTRUCTION AND USE OF AUTOMOBILE SERVICE STATION IN R-3 ZONE AT SOUTHWESTERLY CORNER OF B.PK, BLVD AND TRACY ST., BERNA PERLIN PUBLICATION, NAILING` AND POSTINGS RESUME TESTIMONY IN BEHALF BERNARD PERLIN, 1044 Montego Dr., L.A. PUBLIC HEARING DECLARED CLOSED CP-35 MOTION MADE THAT CITY COUNCIL CONCUR WITH REC. OF PC. THAT CP-35 BE AP- PROVED AND CITY ATTY. INSTRUCTED TO DRAW NEC. RES. CGS REQUIRED MOTION CARRIED PUBLIC HEARING CP-30 CONT'D FROM APRIL 15, 1964) REQUEST TO ALLOW CONSTRUCTION AND USE OF DOG KENNEL IN M-I ZONE AT 1337 N. VIRGINAI AVE., CHARL HAGERMAN AND MARION LE LLYETT PUBLICATION, hAILINC AND POSTINGS BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«I Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council Planning Director Kalbfleisch presented a brief resume of the case and stated that an additional plot plan had been submitted as requested by the City Council but that there was still a need for additional drawings including more definite pinpointing of exactly what was going into the development, Discussion followed that the applicant did not submit five 5) copies of the plot plan as requested. TESTIMONY IN BEHALF OF THE REQUEST WAS CALLED FOR BY MAYOR MOREHEAD. Mr. Charles Hagerman 1335-37 North Virginia, Baldwin Park, stated he had brought with him a larger scale drawing; that he did not understand that he had to have five copies. Planning Director Kalbfleisch commented that he went to Mr. Hagerman's home one Saturday to assist him in making the drawing; that he went to both houses but no one came to the door. He stated that the drawing Mr. Hagerman had with him this evening looked more like what had been requested. As there was no one else in the audience desiring to speak either in behalf of or in opposition to CP-30, Mayor Morehead declared the public hearing closed. COUNCILWOMAN TAYLOR MOVED THAT THE PUBLIC HEARING ON CP-30 BE CONTINUED TO MAY 20, 1964, UNTIL ti^JE GET FIVE COPIES OF THE PLOT PLAN). COUNCILMAN MCCARON SECONDED. City Attorney Flandrick stated the motion would have the effect of reopening the public hearing. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEN TAYLOR, 1JICCARON, ADAIR, GREGORY AND MAYOR MOREHEAD NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE In answer to a question by Mr. Hagerman, Planning Director Kalbfleisch stated the plot plan could be drawn on a scale of one inch to twenty feet. 00- AT 10:10 P.M. COUNC I LWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL RECESS FOR TEN MINUTES. MAYOR MOREHEAD SECONDED. There were no objections, the motion carried and was so ordered by Mayor Morehead. 00- As there were no objections, Mayor Morehead stated that item No. 2 under the Chief Administrative Officer's portion of the Agenda would be taken at this time. Chief Administrative Officer Nordby reviewed his report regarding the renewal of an offer of a police dog to the City by Mr. and Mrs.. Roger C. Taylor, 4242 North La Rica, Baldwin Park. He commented that he did not have a written offer. Mrs. Taylor, 4242 North La Rica, Baldwin Park, stated she would like to offer the dog to the City. Continued) May 6, 1964 Page 15 RESUME X014 TESTIMONY IN BEHALF PUBLIC HEARING DECLARED CLOSED CP-30 MOTION MADE THAT P.H. ON CP-30 BE CONTID TO MAY 20, 1964, UNTIL VIE GET FIVE COPIES OF PLOT PLAN) MOTION CARRIED PLOT PLAN COULD BE DRAWN ON SCALE ON ONE I NCH TO TINIENT' FEET RECESS AT 10:10 P.M, RECONVENED AT 10:20 P.M. ITEM 2 UNDER C.A.O. TAKEN AT THIS TIME REPORT BY C.A.O. NORDBY RE OFFER OF POLICE DOG TO CITY BY hR. AND MRS. ROGER C. TAYLOR, 4242 N. LA RICA, B.PK. MRS. TAYLOR, 4242 N. La Rica, B.Pk. BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council May 6, 1964 1795 Page 16 In answer to a question by Councilman McCaron, Chief C,A.O. NORDBY Administrative Officer Nordby stated the Police Depart- ment was very enthusiastic about getting into this type of activity. He stated two dogs were included in the proposed 1964-65 budget; that the Department felt the use of dogs would be very beneficial in their work and he concurred; that there were many cities using police dogs. Chief of Police Best stated the Police Department would C.O.P. BEST very much like to receive the dog; that it would benefit Baldwin Park; that there were conditions conducive in Baldwin Park to the use of a police dog deep lots that in the instance of prowlers were unlighted and difficult to search a number of commercial buildings where often times it was suspected that there might be a burglar inside due to an open window or door. Officer Lyman E. Baker, 14116 Anada Street, Baldwin Park, stated that the dog was trained and ready to go at any time. Discussion followed regarding the expense wherein it C.O.P. BEST was brought out by Chief of Police Best that by virtue COSTS INVOLVED of the assignment and because of the cleaning problems and additional effort that must be expended by the andler it was recommended in the budget that the handler be paid five percent 5%) above normal patrolman's salary; that the dogs were only used with one man and worked an eight hour shift just as a man did; that the officer would have to take the dog on a five 5) mile hike once a week to keep the dog toned properly; that there was continual retraining; that in addition to the time on duty the officer must spend at least one 1) hour each day keeping the dog well trained; that the dogs were kept at home primarily as a family pet; that should the officer leave the Department or be promoted the dog could be retrained to another officer; that this would necessitate a very short retraining program; that the dog was very attached to Officer Baker. He stated that generally in using dogs the capital outlay would amount to $300.00 dog run and kennel, $250.00 for each dog per year for food; 5% pay increment for the officer; $250.00 for the purchase of each dog; $700.00 training fee that in case of the dog offered the training had been donated); that the total cost for each dog would be approximately $1,500.00; that last years proposed budget was $2,800.00. In answer to a question by Councilwoman Taylor, Chief of Police Best stated that Officer Baker was tentatively assigned to the 8:00 p.m. to 4:00 a.m. shift. There was further discussion wherein City Attorney RE INSURANCE Flandrick stated that the City had a broad point coverage INS. AGENT WOULD insurance policy which would cover this kind of HAVE TO BE NOTIFIED activity; that the premium might be increased but he doubted if there would be any increase unless they saw a substantial loss; and that the agent would have to be notified as this was another area of liability. In answer to a question by Councilwoman Taylor, Chief NOTHING IN CURRENT Administrative Officer Nordby stated there was nothing BUDGET TO TAKE CARE in the current budget to take care of this matter. OF THIS MATTER Mayor Morehead stated as presented last fall Officer Baker and some of his fellow officers agreed to take care of all expenses until June, and up to this time they had. COUNCILWOMAN TAYLOR MOVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL WAIT UNTIL NOTION MADE AFTER THE BUDGET TO DECIDE FOR SURE ON THIS TO SEE WHERE THIS FITS IN). Councilwoman Taylor reworded her motion as follows: MOTION REWORDED Continued) BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council COUNCILV'JOMAN TAYLOR MOVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL WAIT UNTIL BUDGET TIME AND IF THERE IS MONEY FOR THIS THING THAT IT BE RECONSIDERED AT THAT TIME. The motion died for lack of a second. Further discussion followed. In answer to a question by Councilman McCaron, Chief Administrative Officer Nordby stated he was sure the City could find funds for this purpose but it would mean deleting something from the existing) budget by an amendment to the budget. COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL ACCEPT THE DOG AT LEAST FROM NOVJ UNTIL JULY TO SEE, AS MRS, TAYLOR STATED, IF IT FIT, COUNCILMAN MCCARON SECONDED. Councilwoman Taylor stated she was not against this but did not think the dog should be accepted as a gift. MAYOR MOREHEAD MOVED TO AMEND THE MAIN MOTION THAT IF THE MOTION CARRIED THAT MRS. TAYLOR, THE G!JNER OF THE DOG, BE PAID $1.00 FOR WHICH THE CITY WILL HAVE LEGAL CUSTODY TO THIS DOG AND THAT THE CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER BE DIRECTED TO SEARCH THE REMAINING FUNDS AND POSSIBLY APPROPRIATE $75.00 TO CARRY THIS DOG FOR THE BALANCE CF THE FISCAL YEAR. Councilwoman Taylor stated she would be willing to vote on this if she knew where the money was coming from in the future but right now she did not. COUNC I LMAN ADA I R SECONDED. The amendment to the main motion carried as follows: AYES: MAYOR MOREHEAD, COUNCILMEN ADAIR, GREGORY AND MCCARON NOES: COUNCILWOMAN TAYLOR ABSENT: NONE The main motion, as amended, carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEN GREGORY, NCCARON, ADAIR, AND MAYOR MNHEAD NOES: COUNCILWOMAN TAYLOR ABSENT: NONE In answer to a question by Mayor Morehead, Chief of Police Best stated he thought the dog would be used this evening. Mayor Morehead asked that the dog be Iught into the Council Chamber. pictures were taken by the San Gabriel Valley Daily Tribune reporter) May 6, 1964 1096 Page 17 MOTION DIED FOR LACK OF SECOND MOTION MADE THAT CITY COUNCIL ACCEPT DOG AT LEAST FROM NON UNTIL JULY AND TO SEE AS MRS. TYL1R DID STATE IF MOTION MADE TO AMEND MAIN MOTION THAT IF MOTION CARRIED THAT MRS. TAYLOR, OWNER OF DOG, BE PAID $1.0( FOR WHICH CITY WILL HAVE LEGAL CUSTODY TO THIS DOG AND THAT C.A.O. BE DIRECTED T( SEARCH REMAINING FUNDS AND POSSIBLY APPROPRIATE $75.00 T' CARRY THIS DOG FOR BALANCE CF FISCAL YR. AMENDMENT TO MAIN MOOT I ON SECONDED AMENDMENT TO MAIN MOT I ON CARRIED MAIN MOTION, AS AMENDED, CARRIED 00- BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Counci I City Clerk Balkus announced that it was the time and place fixed for the continuation of a public hearing on AZC-4, an application initiated by the Baldwin Park Planning Commission to amend the Baldwin Park Zoning Code by a revision of the C-I neighborhood commercial zone) and C-2 general commercial zone) regulations: Sections 9110 through 9110.91 and 9111 through 9111.91 of the Baldwin Park Zoning Code. Consider repeal of the C-3 highway commercial zone), Sections 9112 through 9112.91 of the Baldwin Park Zonina Code. City Clerk Balkus stated that the proper publication had been accomplished. The City Council considered the comments of the City Attorney made prior to the announcement that this was the time and place for the public hearing that the Council mi ght wish to continue this public hearing to May 20, 1964, to be considered in conjunction with the proposed new zoning ordinance. TESTIM(}IY IN BEHALF OF THE REQUEST WAS CALLED FOR BY tA~OR MOREHEAD. Mr. Pete Schabarum, 109 West College, Covina, stated he was an owner of property surrounding and adjacent to the intersection of Francisquito and Baldwin Park Boulevard; that the intent behind this particular matter was the outgrowth of Zone Case Z-192, a City Council initiated zone case which was approved involving some twenty-three 23) acres in and around that intersection, about six months ago; that the approval and first reading was held at that time; that the second reading of the change of zone was to be effected after the ordinance was modified and this was the outgrowth of that Council action; that this evening the Council had passed two different zone case applications, one of which involved commercial zoning at Tracy and Baldwin Park Boulevard., which the applicant was able to obtain in approximately three 3) months; that he had been involved in two applications and was, he felt, instrumental in getting the City initiated zone change over a period of over two 2) years; that he would appreciate anything that could be done to resolve the zoning so that they could go forward with their develop- ment plans on the property at that intersection. In answer to a question by Councilman McCaron,City Attorney Flandrick stated that Z-192 was unrelated to these regula- tions except that this zone change application indicated the need for the revision of commercial regulations; that the Council held the hearing, introduced the ordinance and they held it and directed the Planning Commission to initiate studies to bring up to date the commercial regula- tions and once these were approved he presumed that Z-192 would be back on the Agenda for the Council's consider- ation. Planning Director Kalbfleisch stated that the Planning Commission and City Council concurred in the fact that a type of development was needed in there that would not permit small lot developments; that under the new regula- tions they would recommend that this be rezoned to C-2 A which would be a minimum of one acre development at any one time, and would require a precise plan on this development. May 6, 1964 Page 18 PUBLIC HEARING AZC-4 CONTtD FFTJM APRIL 15, 1964) INITIATED BY B.PK. P.C. TO AMEND B.PK. ZONING CODE BY REVISION OF C-I AND C-2 REGULATIONS SECTIONS 9110-9110.' AND 9111-9111.91 OF B.PK. ZONING CODE CONSIDER REPEAL OF C-3, SECTIONS 9112- 9112.91 OF B.PK. ZONING CODE PUBLICATION SUGGESTION BY CITY ATTY. THAT COUNCIL MIGHT WISH TO CONSIDER AZC-4 ON MAY 20, 1964, IN CONJUNCTION WITH PROPOSED NEW ZON. ORD. TESTIMONY IN BEHALF PETE SCHABARUM, 109 W. College, Covina RE Z-192 UNDER NEW REG. C-2A WOULD BE FECOItMENDE MIN. OF ONE ACRE DEVELOPMENT AT ANY ONE TIME Continued) BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT AZC-4. PUBLIC NEARING) BE COt'TI"'UED TO MAY 20, 19ti4, TO BE CONSIDERED WITH THE OrH~R A,AENOMENTS TO THE ZONING CODE. COUNCILMAN ADAIR SECONDED. Counc i Imrn McCaron sivgq^=t-d possibly an adjournment of this rr.._ t i ng i r. order tc- s;-ud-/ this mat ter and come to some conclusions. Mayor Morehead stated that the public hearing before the Panning Commission on the proposed new Zoning Ordinance was scheduled for May 12, 1961, and that the Council was requested to be there. Councilman McCaron asked if the changes could be pointed out. City Attorney Flandrick stated that a major change was there was one area devoted to nothing but off-street parking and all uses that were involved in the entire zoning ordinance were listed in one place; that all conditional use permits were listed in one place; that another major change was in the R-3 zone; that an attempt had been made to establish things that the City had not had before, such as open areas devoted to recreational purposes; that there had been some zone eliminations upon the past Council's indication of what they thought was proper, for example, in commercial zones there would be no residential uses as such; that residential uses would be permitted only in conjunction with an existing business. The motion carried by the following vote; AYES: COUNCILMEN GF€GCAII, ADAIR. &CCARON, TAYLOR AND MAYOR MOFElEAD NOES: NONE ABSENT: NOtE 00- City Clerk Butkus announced that it was the time and place fixed for a public hearing on Z-224, an appeal from the denial of the Planning Commission, application submitted by Carl Mossberg and Earl Marron, Jerry Hammond, Agent, for a change of zone from R-1 single family residential zone) to R-2 light multiple family residential zone) or more restrictive use on certain real property located at the rear of properties located at 1322? and 13233 East Fairgrove Street. City Clerk 8e kus stated that the proper publication and mailings had been accomplished. Planning Director Ka lbf l*isch presented a resume of the Case and stated that the Pt" N ConwuissfOn had adopted Reso4ution PC 64-50 denying this case on March 25, 1964_ As there was no one in the audience desiring to speak either in behalf of or in opposition to Z-224, Mayor Morehead declared the public hearing closed. Discussion followed. May 6, 1964. Page 19 MOTION MADE THAT AZC-4 PUBLIC HEARING BE CONTID TO MAY 20, 1964, TO BE CONSIDER[. WITH OTHER AMENDMENTS TO ZON. CODE PUBLIC HEARING P RO- POSE D NEW ZONING ORD. MAY 12, 1964 BEFOM P.C. COUNCIL FEQI,ESTED TO BE THERE CHANGES IN NEW PRO- POSED ZONING ORD. MOTION CARRIED PUBLIC HEARING Z-2211, APPEAL FROM DENIAL OF P.C. REQUESTING ZONE CHG. FROM R-1 TO R-2 AT FEAR OF PROPERTIES LOCATED AT 13227 ANC 13233 E. FAIRGROVE ST., CAM. MOSSBE} AND EARL MARRON, JERRY HAMMONID, AGENT PUBLIC Ai tt AND MAILINGS ASSUME PUBLIC HEARINI Conti nuecd) BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL CONCUR WITH THE FINDINGS OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND DIRECT THE CITY ATTORNEY TO PREPARE A RESOLUTION OF DENIAL. COUNCILMAN MCCARDN SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEN GREGORY, MCCARDN, ADAIR, TAYLOR AND MAYOR MOFEHEAD NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE 00- City Clerk Balkus announced that it was the time and place fixed for a public hearing on Z-225, an appeal from the denial of the Planning Commission, an application submitted by Blue Chip Investments, Incorporated, Latham and Watkins, Attorneys, Agents for a change of zone from R-3 heavy multiple family residential zone) to M-I light, manufacturing zone) or more restrictive use on certain real property located at the northeast corner of East Dalewood Street and North Maine Avenue. City Clerk Balkus stated that the proper publication, mailings and postings had been accomplished. Planning Director Kalbfleisch presented a resume of the case and stated that the Planning Commission had adopted Resolution PC 64-51 denying this case on March 25, 1964. TESTIMONY IN BEHALF OF THE REQUEST V'JAS CALLED FOR BY MAYOR MOREHEAD. Mr. H. R. Stoke, 615 South Flower Street, Los Angeles, asked if Mr. Kalblfeisch would make available the three 3) photographs which had been presented to the Planning Commission. He stated that the applicant had purchased the property with the thought in mind of developing in accordance with M-I uses; that in his opinion the physical May 6, 1964 Page 20 MOTION MADE AND CARRIED THAT CITY COUNCIL CONCUR WITH FINDINGS OF P.C. AND DIRECT CITY ATTY. TO PF€PARE RES. OF DENIAL PUBLIC HEARING Z-225, APPEAL FROM DENIAL OF P.C. REQUESTING ZONE CHG. FROM R-3 TO M-1 ON PROPERTY AT NORTHEAS CORNER OF E. DALEWOO: ST. AND N. MAINE AVE BLUE CHIP INVESTMENT: INC., LATHAM AND WAT. KINS, ATTORNEYS, AGEI PUBLICATION, MAILING: AND POSTINGS RES UME TESTIMONY I N BEHALF H. R. STOI<E, 615 S. Flower, L. A. fact which related to the property lends it to be developed in accordance with those uses and in accordance with the Master Plan; that the property was opposite to what would be M-l which had been just changed to the M-I classification; that there was M-I on the south; that it was on an inter- section with streets on three sides; that the first photo- graph being shown to Council by Mr. Kalbfleisch) showed the property to the north and the immediate proximity of the property to the on and off freeway ramps; that the second photograph was the property to the southwest showing the cafe, the transmission shop and on over to the freeway; that the third photograph was taken of the property directly to the north and on one background the Utility Trailer Company and the property to be rezoned M-I and the freeway; that at the time they appeared before the Planning Commission the protestant who lived in the area was a gentlemen who lived next to the truck parking area immediately opposite the subject property on Maine; that concern was expressed because of the noise, the trucks, the confusion that was now being generated within the area; that if the Council decided to retain the R-3 zone the new R-3 development would be even closer to the distrubing noises, dust and commotion than were those who were within the area now. Mr. Stokes explained that since the Planning Commis- sion action they had looked to find a use which would be more compatible with what the City might hope for; that they had a tentative approval of a service station for that corner; that it only required some one hundred fifty 150) feet along Maine Street; which was acceptable in a C-2 zone subject to a conditional use permit; that he suggested although these things were possible that it would not, in his opinion, Continued) BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council May 6, 1964 Page 21 be good to include or interject into an area which was M-1 on the Master Plana spot C zone or divide a lot in owner- ship, which he guessed was conceivable here, between an M-I and R-3 merely to permit the development Of the property. He said in his opinion it was much better when there was a property owner who did have the desire, and who makes an application, and who wants to develop his property in accordance with the Master Plan, to seize upon that opportunity and permit the property to be developed because if the use was denied now the Council was in effect negating the Master Plan and put off that much further in the future the possibility when the City could be used as it had been planned; that there were a number of safeguards in the use of industrial property adjacent to residential ten 10) foot landscaped yard required on three sides Dalewood); six 6) foot wall along the rear yard; twenty-five 25) foot yard and a fifty 50) foot setback for building, unless a conditional use permit were granted. If the zone change was granted the lot was only one hundred nineteen 119) feet wide and they were undoubtedly going to have to come back to get a conditional use permit for any building located on the premises, and this would afford the Council, at that time, an opportunity to assure whatever safeguards were necessary to the general welfare of the property owners within the area; and that the use would necessarily be consistent to the Master Plan and was one that would be of general benefit to the City and in his opinion merited the Council's consideration. I As there was no one else in the audience desiring to speak PUBLIC HEARING either in behalf of or in opposition to Z-225, Mayor DECLARED CLOSED Morehead declared the public hearing closed. Z-225 Councilman McCaron stated this area was in reference to what he said earlier wherein the Master Plan indicated a usage of an area and the owners have not shown a desire to develop according to the Master Plan; that it would be appear that the Master Plan would be in error to the desires of the persons owning the property; that some consideration should be given to the rest of the property being R-3; that he noticed that Mr. Stoke was considering a lesser zoning as a buffer; that it would appear that there was no other alternative than to accept the recommendation of the Planning Commission. PUBLIC HEARING public hearing on Z-225. REOPENED Z-225 As there were no objections, Mayor Morehead reopened the Mr. Stoke stated that as far as his client was concerned MR. STOKE C-2 with prospects of a conditional use permit would serve the immediate purpose but the principles of planning might be better served with a buffer zone. Councilman'McCaron asked Mr. Kalbfleisch if he had any further suggestion. Planning Director Kalbfleisch stated there was no request for any zone less than M-l that he had knowledge of. Discussion followed. As there was no one else in the audience desiring to speak PUBLIC HEARING either in behalf of or in opposition to Z-225, Mayor DECLARED CLOSED Morehead declared the public hearing closed. Z-225 Discussion followed that apartments to the north would be next to M-I; that if R-3 were permitted industrial would be on the other side; that the property to the west was a truck terminal. 1800 It was brought out that the Council public hearing PUBLIC HEARING notice stated change from R-3 to M-1 or more restrictive NOTICE STATED CHANGE use. FROM R-3 TO M-1 OR MORE RESTRICTIVE USE +1Ggytinued) BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«18C 1 Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council May 6, 1964 COUNCILMAN MCCARON MOVED THAT Z-225 BE REFERRED TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOR FURTHER STUDY ON A LESS RESTRICTIVE ZONE. COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEN MCCARON, GREGORY, ADAIR, TAYLOR AND MAYOR MOREHEAD NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE 00- Mayor Morehead asked if there was anyone in the audience who had business before the Council this evening. Page 22 MOTION MADE AND CARRIED THAT Z-225 RE REFERRED TO P.C. FOR FURTHER STUDY ON LESS RESTRICTIVE ZONE Mr. William Billings stated his interest was in ZV-93, CP-33, ZV-93, CP-33, ZV-94 ZV-93 and CP-34. AND CP-34 TAKEN ON AGENDA AT THIS TIME As there were no objections, Mayor Morehead stated that ZV-93, CP-33, ZV-93 and CP-34 would be taken at this time. City Clerk Balkus announced that it was the time and place PUBLIC HEARING fixed for a public hearing on ZV-93, an application submitted by Richfield Oil Corporation, W. E. Billings, Agent for a ZV-93, REQUEST FOR Variance to allow the construction of a canopy encroaching VARIANCE TO ALLOW into the front ten 10) foot setback and projecting five CONSTRUCTION OF 5) feet over public right-of-way in C-2 general commercial CANOPY ENCROACHING zone), on certain real property located at 14624 East INTO FRONT 10 FT. Garvey Avenue. SETBACK AND PROJECT- ING 5 FT. OVER PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY I N C-2 AT 14624 E. GARVEY AVE., RICHFIELD OIL CORP., W. E. BILLING. AGENT City Clerk Balkus also announced that it was the time and place fixed for a public hearing on CP-33, an application submitted by Richfield Oil Corporation, W. E. Billings, Agent for a Conditional Use Permit to allow the construc- tion and use of an addition and modernization to an exist- ing Automobile Service Station on certain real property located at 14624 East Garvey Avenue, in C-2 general commercial zone. City Clerk Balkus stated that the proper publication, mailings and postings had been accomplished on ZV-93 and CP-33. Planning Director Kalbfleisch presented a resume of the cases and stated that the Planning Commission had adopted Resolution PC 64-61 recommending approval of ZV-93 on April 8, 1964 and had adopted Resolution PC 64-60 recommending approval of CP-33 on April 8, 1964. TESTIMONY IN BEHALF OF ZV-93 V!AS CALLED FOR BY MAYOR MOREHEAD. Mr. William Billings, Agent for Richfield Oil Corporation, stated this was an existing service station; that they were proposing to construct a canopy over the pump island which would bring the canopy to the property line which would be using the ten 10) foot setback area and relocating the sign to the east property line; that they propose to modernize the station; that their customers were almost demanding protection from the weather when they pull in for service; that they concurred with the Planning Commis- sion. Continued) PUBLIC HEARING CP-33, REQUEST TO ALLOW CONSTRUCTION AND USE OF ADDITION AND MODERNIZATION TO EXISTING AUTOMOBILE SERVICE STATION AT 14624 E. GARVEY AVE., IN C-2 ZONE, RICHFIELD OIL CORP.,- V1. E. BILLINGS, AGEN' PUBLICATION, MAILING' AND POSTINGS RESUME TESTIMONY IN BEHALF ZV-93 WM. BILLINGS, AGENT FOR RICHFIELD OIL CORP. BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council As there was no one else in the audience desiring to speak either in behalf of or in opposition to ZV-93, Mayor Morehead declared the public hearing closed. COUNCILMAN MCCARON MOVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL INSTRUCT THE CITY ATTORNEY TO DRAW THE NECESSARY RESOLUTION TO APPROVE ZV-93t MAYOR MOREHEAD SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMAN IW CARON, MAYOR MOREHEAD, COUNCILMEN ADAIR, GREGORY AND TAYLOR NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE May 6, 1964 Page 23 PUBLIC HEARING DECLARED CLOSED ZV-93 MOTION MADE AND CARRIED THAT CITY COUNCIL INSTRUCT CITY ATTY. TO DRM'J NEC. RES. TO APPROVE ZV-93 TESTIMONY IN BEHALF OF CP-33 WAS CALLED FOR BY MAYOR TESTIMONY IN BEHALF MOREHEAD. CP-33 Mr. William Billings, Agent for Richfield Oil Corporation, WM. BILLINGS stated they proposed to modernize the existing service station;AGENT FOR RICHFIELD that they proposed to put a new cornice around it along OIL CORP. with the canopy and bring it up to the latest standards, as far as modernization was concerned. As there was no one else in the audience desiring to speak either in behalf of or in opposition to CP-33, Mayor More- head declared the public hearing closed. COUNCILMAN MCCARON MOVED THAT THE CITY ATTORNEY BE INSTRUCTED TO DRAW THE NECESSARY RESOLUTION APPROVING CP-33. COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEN NCCARON, GREGORY, ADAIR, TAYLOR AND MAYOR MOREHEAD NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE 00- i City Clerk Balkus announced that it was the time and place fixed for a public hearing on ZV-94, an application submitted by Richfield Oil Corporation, W. E. Billings, Agent for a Vairance to allow the construction of a canopy encroaching into the front ten 10) foot setback and a sign encroaching into the front ten 10) foot setback and projecting five 5) feet over public right-of-way, in C-1 neighborhood commercial zone) on certain real property located at 13011 East Garvey Avenue. City Clerk Balkus also announced that it was the time and place fixed for a public hearing on CP-34, an application submitted by Richfield Oil Corporation, W. E. Billings, Agent for a Conditional Use Permit to allow the construc- tion and use of an addition and modernization of an Automobile Service Station in C-I neighborhood commercial zone) on certain real property located at 13011 East Garvey Avenue. City Clerk Balkus stated that the proper publication, mailings and postings had been accomplished on ZV-94 and CP-34. PUBLIC HEARING DECLARED CLOSED CP-33 MOTION MADE AND CARRIED THAT CITY ATTY. BE INSTRUCTED TO DRAW NEC. RES. APPROVING CP-33 PUBLIC HEARING ZV-94, REQUEST TO A L LOUD CONSTRUCT ION OF CANOPY ENCROACH I N( INTO FRONT 10 FT, SETBACK AND SIGN ENCROACHING INTO FRONT 10 FT. SET- BACK AND PROJECTING 5 FT. OVER PUBLIC RIGHT-OF4JAY I N C-1 ZONE, 13011 E. GARVE' AVE., RICHFIELD OIL CORP., W. E. BILLING: AGENT PUBLIC HEARING CP-34, REQUEST TO ALLOW CONSTRUCTION AND USE OF ADDITION AND MODERNIZATION OF AUTOMOBILE SERVICE STATION IN C-1 ZONE AT 13011 E. GARVEY AVE., RICHFI.ELD OIL CORP., V.I. E. BILLING' AGENT PUBLICATION), MAILING AND POSTINGS Continued) BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council May 6, 1964 Page 24 Planning Director Kalbfleisch presented a,resume of the RESUME cases and stated that the Planning Commission had adopted Resolution PC 64-63 recommending approval of ZV-94 on April 8, 1964, and had adopted Resolution PC 64-62 recommending approval of CP-34 on April 8, 1964. TESTIMONY IN BEHALF OF ZV-94 WAS CALLED FOR BY MAYOR MOREHEAD, Mr. William Billings, Agent for Richfield Oil Corporation, stated it was the same circumstances as ZV-93 and CP-33), same type of modernization and so forth. As there was no one else in the audience desiring to speak either in behalf of or in opposition to ZV-94, Mayor Morehead declared the public hearing closed. Councilwoman Taylor asked if she understood that the sign would be permitted to encroach over the public right-of-way as stated in PC 64-63. TESTIMONY IN BEHALF ZV-94 WM. BILLINGS, AGENT FOR RICHFIELD O I L CORP. PUBLIC HEARING DECLARED CLOSED ZV-94 As there were no objections, Mayor Morehead reopened the PUBLIC HEARING public hearing on ZV-94. REOPENED ZV-94 Mr. Billings stated this sign now existed in the right-of-way; MR. BILLINGS that they were proposing to raise the sign. As there was no one else in the audience desiring to speak either in behalf of or in opposition to ZV-94, Mayor Morehead declared the public hearing closed. COUNCILWOMAN TAYLOR MOVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL CONCUR WITH THE FINDINGS OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND THAT ZV-94 BE GRANTED AND THE CITY ATTORNEY BE INSTRUCTED TO DRAW THE PROPER RESOLUTION. COUNCILMAN ADAIR SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEN TAYLOR, ADAIR, GREGORY, MCCARON AND MAYOR MOREHEAD NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE TESTIMONY IN BEHALF OF CP-34 WAS CALLED FOR BY MAYOR MOREHEAD. Mr. William Billings, Agent for Richfield Oil Corporation, stated this was also the modernizing of an existing service station. As there was no one else in the audience desiring to speak either in behalf of or in opposition to CP-34, Mayor Morehead declared the public hearing closed. COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT CP-34 BE APPROVED AND DIRECT THE CITY ATTORNEY TO PREPARE A RESOLUTION OF APPROVAL. MAYOR MOREHEAD SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote; AYES: COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY, MAYOR MOREHEAD, COUNCILMEN ADAIR, MCCARON AND TAYLOR NOES NONE ABSENT: NONE 00- PUBLIC HEARING DECLARED CLOSED ZV-94 MOTION MADE AND CARRIED THAT CITY COUNCIL CONCUR WITH FINDINGS CF P.C. AND THAT ZV-94 BE GRANTED AND CITY ATTY. INSTRUCTED TO DRAW PROPER RES. TESTIMONY IN BEHALF CP-34 WM. BILLINGS, AGENT FOR RICHFIELD OIL CORP. PUBLIC HEARING DECLARED CLOSED CP-34 MOTION MADE AND CARRIED THAT CP-34 LA APPROVED AND DIRECT' CITY ATTY. TO PRE- PARE RES. OF APPROVE City Clerk Balkus presented a claim against the City of CLAIM AGAINST CITY Baldwin Park by Jerry D. Spaulding. JERRY D. SPAULDING COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT THE CLAIM BE DENIED AND RE- MOTION MADE AND FERRED TO THE INSURANCE CARRIER. COUNCILMAN MCCARON SECONDED. CARRIED THAT CLAIM The motion carried by the following vote: BE DENIED AND RE- AYES: COUNCILMEN GREGORY, MCCARON, ADAIR, FERRED TO INS. TAYLOR AND MAYOR MOREHEAD CARRIER NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE OO- BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«1804 May 6, 1961 Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council Page 25 City Clerk Balkus presented a claim against the City of Baldwin Park by Carl F. Schultz. COUNCILWOMAN TAYLOR MOVED THAT THE CLAIM BE DENIED AND REFERRED TO THE INSURANCE CARRIER. MAYOR MOFEHEAD SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILWOMAN TAYLOR, MAYOR MOREHEAD, COUNCILMEN ADAIR, GREGORY AND MCCARON NOES; NONE ABSENT: NONE 00- Discussion followed regarding adjournment to another dates COUNCILWOMAN TAYLOR MOVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL CONTINUE WITH PUBLIC HEARINGS II, 12 AND 13. COUNCILMAN MCCARON SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEN TAYLOR, MCCARON, ADAIR, GREGORY AND MAYOR MOREHEAD NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE 00- City Clerk Balkus announced that it was the time and place fixed for a public hearing on Z-227, an application initiated by the Baldwin Park Planning Commission to initiate a change of zone from C-3 highway commercial zone) to C-2 general commercial zone) or more restrictive use on all property presently in C-3, bounded by Vineland Avenue on the east, Francisquito Avenue on the south and Dalewood Street on the west. City Clerk Balkus stated that the-proper publication and mailings had been accomplished. Planning Director Kalbfleisch presented a resume of the case and stated that the Planning Commission had adopted Resolution PC 614-55 recommending approval on April 8, 1964. As there was no one in the audience desiring to speak in behalf of or in opposition to Z-227, Mayor Morehead declared the public hearing closed. Discussion followed. City Clerk Balkus read Ordinance No. 355 by title as follows: ORDINANCE NO. 355 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BALDWIN PARK AMENDING THE ZONING MAP OF SAID CITY AND REZONING CERTAIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY FROM C-3 TO C-2" COUNCILWOMAN TAYLOR MOVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL CONCUR WITH THE FINDINGS OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND THAT ORDINANCE NO. 355 PASS FIRST READING AND FURTHER READING BE WAIVED. COUNCILMAN GREGORY SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEN TAYLOR, GREGORY, ADAIR, MCCARON AND MAYOR MOREHEAD NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE CLAIM AGAINST CITY CARL F. SCHULTZ MOTION MADE AND CARRIED THAT CLAIM BE DENIED AND FE- FERRED TO INS. CARRIE R DISC. RE ADJOURN- MENT MOTION MADE AND CARRIED THAT CITY COUNCIL CONTINUE WITH P.H. 11, 12 AND 13 PUBLIC HEARING Z-227, REQUESTING CHG. OF ZONE FROM C-3 TO C-2 ON ALL PROPERTY PRESNTLY IN C-3 BOUNDED BY VINELAND AVE. ON EAST, F RANCI SQUI TO AVE. ON SOUTH AND DALEWOOD ST. ON WES7 PUBLICATION AND MAILINGS RESUME PUBLIC HEARING DECLARED CLOSED Z-227 ORD. NO. 355 AMEND. ZONING MAP OF SAID CITY AND REZONING CERTAIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY FROM C-3 TO C-2 MOTION MADE AND CARRIED THAT CITY COUNCIL CONCUR WITH FINDINGS OF P.C. ANC THAT ORD. NO. 355 PASS FIRST READING AND FURTHER READING WAIVED 00- BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í« Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council May 6, 1964 1805 P 6 age 2 City Clerk Ba lk us announced that it was the time and place PUBLIC HEARING fixed for a public hearing on ZV-92, an application submitted by Signal Oil Company, B. P. Cravens, Agent, for a Variance ZV-92, REQUEST TO to allow the construction of an addition and signs and ALLOW CONSTRUCTION light columns encroaching into the front ten 10) foot OF ADDITION AND setback in the C-I neighborhood commercial zone), on SIGNS AND LIGHT certain real property located at 13800 Los Angeles Street. COLUMNS ENCROACHING INTO FRONT TEN 10) FT. SETBACK IN C-I ZONE AT 13800 L.A. ST., SIGNAL OIL CO., B.P. CRAVENS AGENT City Clerk Balkus also announced that it was the time and place fixed for a public hearing on CP-32, an application submitted by Signal Oil Company, B. P. Cravens, Agent, for a Conditional Use Permit to allow construction and use of an addition and modernization to an existing Automobile Service Station, in C-I neighborhood commercial zone), on certain real property located at 13800 East Los Angeles Street. City Clerk Balkus stated that the proper publication, mailings and postings had been accomplished on ZV-92 and CP-32. Planning Director Kalbfleisch presented a resume of the cases and stated that the Planning Commission had adopted Resolution PC 64-59 recommending approval of ZV-92 on April 8, 1964, and had adopted Resolution PC 61i-58 recommending approval of CP-32 on April 8, 1964. As there was no one in the audience desiring to speak either in behalf of or in opposition to ZV-92, Mayor Morehead declared the public hearing closed. Councilwoman Gregory asked if there had been a permi t issued to install that canopy. She stated that the canopy was nearly ready for painting. Building Superintendent Kalbfleisch stated he would check it out tomorrow and give them a red tag. COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT ZV-92 BE APPROVED AND DIRECT THAT THE CITY ATTORNEY PREPARE A RESOLUTION OF APPROVAL. COUNCILMAN ADAIR SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: DUNCILMEN GREGORY, ADAIR, MCCARON, TAYLOR AND MAYOR MOREHEAD NOES NONE ABSENT: NONE As there was no one in the audience desiring to speak either in behalf of or in opposition to CP-32, Mayor Morehead declared the public hearing closed. COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT CP-32 BE APPROVED AND DIRECT THE CITY ATTORNEY TO PREPARE A RESOLUTION OF APQV~4AL COUNCILMAN ADAI R SEODNDE D. The mot ion carried by the sowing vote: AYI 4 CkWC11 A€N UFF.GORY, ADAIR. a Af:*)N. TAYLOR AND MAYOR ofi-EAD NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE PUBLIC HEARING CP-32, BEQUEST TO ALLOW CONSTRUCTION AND USE OF ADDITION AND MODERNIZATION TO EXISTING AUTOMOB. SERVICE STATION IN C-I ZONE AT 13800 E. L.A. ST., SIGNAL OIL CO., B. P. CRAVENS, AGENT PUBLICATION, MAILING AND POSTINGS RESUME PUBLIC HEARING DECLARED CLOSED ZV-92 RE WORK ON CANOPY READY FOR PAINTING BLDG. SUPT. TO CHECK OUT AND GIVE RED TAG MOTION MADE AND CARRIED THAT ZV-92 BE APPROVED AND DIRECT THAT CITY ATTY. PREPARE RES. OF APPROVAL PUBLIC HEARING DECLARED CLOSED CP-32 MOTION MADE AND CARRIED THAT CP-3< BE APPROvEiY AA* DIRECT CITY ATTY. TO PREPARE RES. or ApPsIpVAL BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council City Clerk Balkus stated that the League of California Cities was holding its Mayors and Councilmen Institute on May 17-19, 1964, in Santa Monica; that reservations should be made at this time if any of the Council wish to attend; that the registration fees were $15.00 for each person and the hotel room was $10.00 a night for a single and $15.00 for a double. May 6, 1964 Page 27 LEAGUE OF CALIF. CITIES MAYORS AND COUNCILMEN INSTITUTE MAY 17-19, 1964 IN SANTA MONICA Councilwoman Gregory indicated she would like to attend and Councilwoman Taylor stated she would advise the City Clerk on May 7, 1964, as to whether or not she would attend. I COUNCILMAN MCCARCN MOVED THAT ANY MEMBER OF THE COUNCIL WHO DESIRED TO ATTEND THIS MEETING LEAGUE OF CALIFORNIA CITIES MAYORS AND COUNCILMEN INSTITUTE) IN SANTA MONICA ON THE DATES GIVEN BY THE CITY CLE R+C MAY 17-19, 1964) MAY DO SO AND SUBMIT AN EXPENSE ACCOUNT. MAYOR MOREHEAD SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMAN MCCARCN, MAYOR MOREHEAD, COUNCILMEN ADAIR AND GREGORY NOES: NONE ABSTAIN: COUNCILWOMAN TAYLOR ABSENT: NONE MOTION MADE AND CARRIED THAT ANY MEMBER OF COUNCIL WHO DESIRED TO ATTEND THIS MTG. LEAGUE OF CALIF. CITIES MAYORS AND COUNCILMEN INSTITUTE IN SANTA MONICA ON DATES GIVEN BY CITY CLEF4( MAY 17- 19, 1964) MAY Do so AND SUBMIT AN EX- PENSE ACCOUNT 00- Discussion followed regarding an adjournment date to finish matters on the Agenda. Chief Administrative Officer Nordby reported that he had had a meeting on Monday, May 4, 1964, with two insurance men regarding the retirement program. He stated they offered to come on Friday to explain the program to the City Council and he suggested that the City Council adjourn to 4:00 p.m. on Friday, May 8, 1964. He stated the re- tirement plan was proposed by Bankers Life of Des Moines. AT 12:45 A.M. COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL ADJOURN TO FRIDAY, MAY 8, 1964, AT 4:00 P.M. IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBER OF THE CITY HALL. MAYOR MOREHEAD SECONDED. The motion carried by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY, MAYOR MOREHEAD, COUNCILMEN ADAIR, MCCAF30N AND TAYLOR NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE 00- DISC. OF ADJ. DATE TO FINISH MATTERS ON AGENDA C.A.O. NOROBY SUGGESTED COUNCIL ADJ. TO FRI. MAY 8, 1964, FOR EXPLANA- TION OF INS. P RO- GRAM ADJ. AT 12:45 A.M. TO FRI. MAY 8, 1964, AT 4:00 P.M. IN COUNCIL CHAMBER OF CITY HALL APPFOVED: May 20 1964. Date of Distribution to City Council May 15 1964. Date of Distribution to Departments May 18 1964. BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«REGULAR MEETING OF THE BALDWIN PARK CITY COUNCIL MAY 6, 1964 CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBER) 1103 East Pacific Avenue 7:30 P.M. The City Council of the City of Baldwin Park met in regular session at the above place at 7:30 p.m. Councilman McCaron led the salute to the flag. FLAG SALUTE The invocation was given by Pastor Vernon Kutz of the INVOCATION Church of the Nazarene. Roll Call: Present: COUNCILMEN ADAIR, GREGORY, MCCARON, TAYLOR AND MAYOR MOREHEAD ROLL CALL Absent: NONE Also Present: CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER NORDBY, CITY ATTORNEY FLANDRICK, CITY ENGINEER YOUNG, PLANNING DIRECTOR AND BUILDING SUPERINTENDENT KALBFLEISCH, ASSISTANT PLANNING DIRECTOR HILL, FINANCE DIRECTOR DUNCAN, CHIEF OF POLICE BEST, CITY TREASURER PUGH AND CITY CLERK BALKUS 00- AT 12:45 A.M. COUNCILWOMAN GREGORY MOVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL ADJOURNMENT AT ADJOURN TO FRIDAY, MAY 8, 1964, AT 4:00 P.M. IN THE COUNCIL 12:45 A.M. TO FRI., CHAMBER OF THE CITY HALL. MAYOR MOREHEAD SECONDED. The MAY 8, 1964, AT motion carried by the following vote: 4:00 P.M. IN COUNCIL CHAMBER OF CITY HALL AYES: COUNCILMAN GREGORY, MAYOR MOREHEAD, COUNCILMEN ADAIR, MCCARON AND TAYLOR NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE 00- THELMA L. BALKUS, CITY CLERK DATED: May 7, 1964 TIME: /OfOc? A.M. BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 1964 05 06 CC MINHÄ—@¸—6 Í«STATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES SS: AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING NOTICE CITY OF BALDWIN PARK OF A JO'RN E THELMA L. BALKUS, being first duly sworn, says and deposes: that I am the duly chosen, qualified and acting City Clerk of the City Council of the City of Baldwin Park; that at a Regular Meeting of the City Council of the City of Baldwin Park held May 6 1964. said meeting was ordered adjourned to the time and place specified in the Notice of the Adjournment ATTACHED HERETO; that on F May 7 1961E at the hQOr of 10:00 a.m., I posted a copy of said Notice at a conspicuous place on or near the door of the place at which said meeting of May 6 1964 was held. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 1//_1 day of 19 fv atr f..,~,L~f r Notary PublI c in and f,ot said County and State I EVA ELDER PUGH, Notary Public. State of California Principal Office, Los Angeles County My Commission Expires March 6, 1967 4657 North Merced Ave.. Baldwin Park, Calif. VIII Ilala1111a111111a11111ryI111111111111111N11111111111111111111 OFFICIAL SEAL EVA ELDER PUGH NO,ARY PUBLIC 1 AL,ruRr.4 PRINCIPAL OFFICE IN 11YIOM NMYO11104NY1 THE LAMA L. ALKU CITY LOS ANGELES COUNTY BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06 Í«1017'01 Regular Meeting of the Baldwin Park City Council AYES: COUNCILMEN GREGORY, ADAIR, TAYLOR AND MAYOR MOREHEAD NOES: COUNCILMAN MCCARON ABSENT: NONE 00- City Clerk Balkus announced that it was the time and place fixed for the continuation of a public hearing on Z-228, an application submitted by Bernard Perlin for a change of zone from R-3 heavy multiple family residential zone) to C-2 general commercial zone)or more restrictive use on certain real property located at the southwesterly corner of Baldwin Park Boulevard and Tracy Street. City Clerk Balkus stated that the proper publication and mailings had been accomplished. Planning Director Kalbfleisch presented a resume of the case and stated that the Planning Commission had adopted Resolution PC 64-56 recommending approval on April 8, 1964. TESTIMONY IN BEHALF OF THE REQUEST WAS CALLED FOR BY MAYOR PlOREHEAD. Mr. Bernard Perlin, 1044 Montego Drive, Los Angeles, architects and engineers, stated that the subject property was at the on and off ramp of the San Bernardino Freeway and at what they believed would be the main entry to the City of Baldwin Park; that the subject development was reviewed by the Planning Commis- sion and very stringent requirements had been placed upon the development in the form of landscaping and type of buildings involved; that they had prepared a rendering of the proposed development which he showed) indicating what their study indicated would be the potential for the surrounding area; that they worked with the Planning Department in making the study; that the subject property would be developed with a major restaurant, coffee house type; that he felt this would be a catalyst for the entire area; that adjoining the development would be a ranch type Texaco Service Station at the corner of Tracy and Baldwin Park Boulevard; that it would be surrounded by streets on three sides; that in his opinion this develop- ment would be an asset to the City. Mr. J. C. Snyder, 13554 East Tracy, Baldwin Park, stated their original plan one and one-half years ago was to develop the property R-3; that since the Highway Patrol Department had moved in they did not feal it would be advantageous to rent apartments; that having streets on three sides offered hazards to children that would be in the apartments; that there was a need for a service station in this area. Mr. Robert Ficke, 814 Wocdcroft, Glendora, stated he owned the last lot on the southern portion on this property; that he purchased the property with the intention of building an apartment house but at the present time could not proceed properly with it; that it was adjacent to the freeway and there was a noise factor; that the island there would be ideal as a commercial piece of property. As there was no one else in the audience desiring to speak either in behalf of or in opposition to Z-228, Mayor Morehead declared the public hearing closed. May 6, 1964 Page 12 PUBLIC HEARING Z-228 CONT'D FROM APRIL 15, 1964) REQUESTING CHANGE OF ZONE FROM R-3 TO C-2 AT SOUTHWESTERLY CORNER OF B.PK. BLVD. AND TRACY ST., BERNP PERLIN PUBLICATION AND MAILINGS RESUME TESTIMONY IN BEHALF BERNARD PERLIN, 1044 Montego Dr., L,i J. C. SNYDER, 13554 E. Tracy, B.Pk. ROBERT FICKE 8.14 V10ODCROFT,aGLENDO{ PUBLIC HEARING DECLARED CLOSED Z-228 Discussion followed that this request was for both sides Continued) BIB] 39576-U01 1964-U02 05-U02 06-U02 CC-U02 MIN-U02 LI1-U03 FO9994-U03 FO115493-U03 DO116814-U03 C4-U03 MINUTES1-U03 4/24/2008-U04 ROBIN-U04 REGULAR-U05 SESSION-U05 CITY-U06 COUNCIL-U06